First orders and the Laken Riley Act
On Jan. 20, 2025, Donald Trump began his second term as president and signed a set of orders on the border and deportations the same day. He declared a national emergency at the southern border, shut down the app that migrants used to book asylum appointments and suspended refugee admissions. The next day the Department of Homeland Security let ICE officers make arrests at schools and churches and widened expedited removal, which lets officers deport some people without a hearing before a judge. The first bill Trump signed was the Laken Riley Act, which requires ICE to detain immigrants without legal status who are charged with theft and some other crimes. Twelve Senate Democrats and 46 House Democrats voted for it. In February, Senate Republicans adopted a budget resolution that allowed up to $175 billion for the border and immigration enforcement. In mid-March, Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, and the government flew about 250 men to a prison in El Salvador, which led to fights in the courts and on the Senate floor.
- Senate hearing · Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee: Remain in Mexico and the President's border powers
A Senate hearing on Remain in Mexico turns to deportations and the Laken Riley Act
The Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee met four days before Trump took office to ask whether a President has enough power at the border under current law. Most of the hearing was about Remain in Mexico, a policy that sent asylum seekers back to Mexico to wait for their court dates. Ken Cuccinelli, a former acting deputy secretary of DHS, said deportations would be "logistically challenging" and would need support from Congress. Sen. Ruben Gallego (D-AZ) asked where the government could deport people whose home countries will not take them back. Adam Isacson of the Washington Office on Latin America, the witness Democrats invited, said there was "no great answer." Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO) asked Isacson about words he wrote in 2024 after Laken Riley's murder. Isacson said the Laken Riley Act "could do a lot of harm," and Hawley called it "absolutely necessary."
Who said whatWe chose these 4 exchanges between senators and witnesses to show the arguments about deportation. All come from one Senate hearing on Jan 16, 2025, “Remain in Mexico”, which had 243 statements.
- Senate hearing · Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee: confirmation of Kristi Noem
Noem answers senators' questions at her confirmation hearing
Before the full Senate votes on a President's choice for a top post, a committee questions the nominee in public. Kristi Noem, Trump's pick to run DHS, appeared before the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee three days before he took office. She said deporting people with criminal convictions would come first, then people with final removal orders. She said the CBP One app would be shut down on her first day. Democrats asked who would run the border, she or Trump's border czar, Tom Homan, and said farms would lose workers. Republicans asked her to end the release of migrants while their cases wait.
Who said whatWe chose these 5 questions and Noem's answers to show the main arguments. All come from one Senate hearing on Jan 17, 2025, “Nomination of Hon. Kristi Noem”, which had 249 statements.
- Trump signs orders on the border and deportations on his first day
Trump declared a national emergency at the southern border, which let the military help build barriers and send troops there. A proclamation suspended "the physical entry of aliens involved in an invasion" across the southern border. Other orders suspended refugee admissions from Jan. 27, named drug cartels as terrorist organizations and sought to end automatic citizenship for some children born in the U.S. That afternoon, Customs and Border Protection shut down the CBP One app, which had been the only way to book an asylum appointment at the southwest border, and canceled all pending appointments.
- Senate floor · S. 5: an amendment vote, a blocked request and the vote on passage
The Senate passes the Laken Riley Act
Sen. Katie Britt (R-AL) wrote the Senate's Laken Riley Act (S. 5). It requires ICE to detain immigrants without legal status who are charged with or arrested for theft, burglary or shoplifting. On Inauguration Day the Senate added Sen. Joni Ernst's (R-IA) amendment, known as Sarah's Law, 75–24. It also requires detention for people charged with crimes that kill or seriously injure someone. Sen. Michael Bennet (D-CO) asked to offer an amendment that would have set aside some minors. Britt objected, which blocked it. The bill passed 64–35, with 12 Democrats joining all 52 Republicans.
Senate votePassing the Laken Riley ActEarlier the same day, the Senate added Sen. Joni Ernst's amendment, S.Amdt. 8, 75–24.
64–35Bill Passed64 yes0 did not vote35 noRepublicans: 52 yes, 0 no. Democrats: 12 yes, 33 no. Independents: 0 yes, 2 no.The clerk recorded this vote as “On Passage of the Bill S. 5”.Who said whatWe chose these 6 statements to show the main arguments members made. They come from 3 debates on Jan 20, 2025.
- DHS lets ICE make arrests at schools and churches and widens fast-track deportation
DHS dropped a Biden-era policy that had kept ICE and Border Patrol agents from making arrests at or near schools, places of worship and health care facilities. "Criminals will no longer be able to hide in America's schools and churches to avoid arrest," a DHS spokesperson said. The same evening a DHS notice took effect that let officers use expedited removal anywhere in the country for people who cannot show they have been in the U.S. for two years. Before, it was mostly limited to people caught within 100 miles of the border within 14 days of crossing.
- Senate and House floors · Floor speeches and the Senate vote on Kristi Noem for Secretary of Homeland Security
The Senate confirms Noem, and members debate Trump's first orders
The Senate must confirm a President's choices for top posts. Kristi Noem, the governor of South Dakota, was Trump's pick to run DHS, which includes ICE and Border Patrol. Sen. Alex Padilla (D-CA) said she had made false claims about immigrants in her hearing. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) said he backed her because she would enforce the law. She was confirmed 59–34 on Jan. 25, with seven Democrats voting yes. In speeches on the new orders, Democrats objected to arrests at schools and churches and to arrests of people with no criminal record. Republicans pointed to arrests of people with criminal records and to deportation flights.
Who said whatWe chose these 9 statements to show the main arguments members made. They come from 6 debates between Jan 21 and Feb 6, 2025.
- House hearing · Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration Integrity, Security, and Enforcement: immigration enforcement after Trump's first orders
A House subcommittee argues over deportations two days after Trump's first orders
A subcommittee is a smaller group of a committee's members that works on one subject. Two days after Trump's first orders, this House Judiciary subcommittee heard four witnesses on immigration enforcement. Its chair, Rep. Tom McClintock (R-CA), said the administration must now undertake "the largest repatriation operation in history." John Fabbricatore, a retired ICE field office director, said removals deter others from coming and asked Congress to pay for more officers and detention beds and to stop funding sanctuary jurisdictions. Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-MD) asked what deporting 12 million people would do to the economy, and David Bier of the Cato Institute, the witness Democrats invited, said it would shrink the economy by $2 trillion a year. Rep. Steve Cohen (D-TN) asked about the Laken Riley Act and whether people brought here as children under DACA should be deported. Fabbricatore said criminals should come first but that anyone breaking immigration law must at some point face "a reckoning."
Who said whatWe chose these 6 questions and the witnesses' answers to show the main arguments. All come from one House hearing on Jan 22, 2025, “Restoring Immigration Enforcement in America”, which had 437 statements.
- House floor · S. 5: the rule, floor debate and vote
The House sends the Laken Riley Act to Trump
The House had passed a version of the bill by Rep. Mike Collins (R-GA) earlier in January. Before taking up the Senate's version, it adopted the rule that set the terms of debate, 213–204. Republicans said the bill would keep people like Laken Riley's killer off the streets. They noted that it also lets states sue federal officials who do not enforce immigration law. Democrats said it was redundant and would let people be detained on an accusation alone. They also said ICE had no money to carry it out. It passed 263–156, with 46 Democrats joining the 217 Republicans who voted. Trump signed it on Jan. 29.
House voteFinal passage of the Laken Riley ActThe Senate had passed it 64–35 on Jan. 20, so this House vote sent it to the President.
263–156Passed263 yes14 did not vote156 noRepublicans: 217 yes, 0 no. Democrats: 46 yes, 156 no.The clerk recorded this vote as “On Passage”.Who said whatWe chose these 8 statements to show the main arguments members made. All come from one House debate on Jan 22, 2025, “Senate Bill 5: Laken Riley Act”, which had 18 statements.
- Colombia turns back U.S. military deportation flights, then agrees to take them
Two Air Force cargo planes had carried deported migrants to Guatemala on Jan. 24. Colombia's President Gustavo Petro turned back two military planes, saying migrants should come home on civilian planes and "without being treated like criminals." Trump ordered visa limits and said he would put a 25 percent tariff on Colombian goods. That night the White House said Colombia had agreed to all of its terms, including flights on military aircraft, and held the tariffs back. Colombia said it would send its presidential plane to bring the migrants home.
- Trump signs the Laken Riley Act and orders a migrant center at Guantanamo Bay
The law was the first of Trump's second term. Laken Riley's family and Sen. John Fetterman (D-PA), the first Senate Democrat to cosponsor it, attended the signing. Earlier in January, ICE had told lawmakers the law would cost $26 billion in its first year and was "impossible to execute with existing resources." At the signing, Trump said he would hold up to 30,000 migrants at the U.S. naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and he signed a memorandum to expand the migrant center there.
WATCH LIVE: Trump signs Laken Riley Act, law making it easier to detain people in U.S. illegallyPBS NewsHour · Watch on YouTube ↗ - The first migrant detainees are flown to Guantanamo
A plane carrying 10 detainees left Fort Bliss, Texas, for the naval base. U.S. officials told CBS News the men were Venezuelans with ties to the Tren de Aragua gang. CBS also reported that ICE was averaging 800 to 1,000 arrests a day, up from an average of 312 a day in President Biden's fourth year in office.
- House floor · H.R. 35: floor debate and vote
The House makes fleeing Border Patrol a federal crime
Rep. Juan Ciscomani (R-AZ) wrote the bill, named for a Border Patrol agent who died in December 2022 while chasing a group of migrants. It makes it a federal crime to flee from Border Patrol or other officers in a vehicle within 100 miles of the border. For noncitizens, fleeing would also be a ground for deportation or for being kept out of the country. Democrats said fleeing Border Patrol was already a crime and already made a person deportable. They also said the bill would reach U.S. citizens and people who were never charged. It passed 264–155, with 50 Democrats joining the Republicans, and went to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
House votePassing the Agent Raul Gonzalez Officer Safety Act264–155Passed264 yes14 did not vote155 noRepublicans: 214 yes, 0 no. Democrats: 50 yes, 155 no.The clerk recorded this vote as “On Passage”.Who said whatWe chose these 6 statements to show the main arguments members made. All come from one House debate on Feb 13, 2025, “House Bill 35: Agent Raul Gonzalez Officer Safety Act”, which had 19 statements.
The Senate adopts a budget plan with $175 billion for the border and deportations
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC), chairman of the Budget Committee, wrote a budget resolution that opened the way for reconciliation, a fast track that avoids the filibuster. It let the Judiciary and Homeland Security committees write a plan of up to $175 billion for the border and immigration enforcement, with $150 billion for defense and $20 billion for the Coast Guard. Graham and Sen. John Barrasso (R-WY) said Trump's border czar, Tom Homan, had told them ICE was running out of money. Democrats said the money could pay for private prisons and mass deportation. Sen. Patty Murray's (D-WA) amendment to strike the fast-track instructions failed 47–53. The resolution was adopted 52–48 early on Feb. 21. Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) was the only Republican to vote no. On Feb. 25 the House adopted its own budget plan, H.Con.Res. 14, 217–215.
Senate voteAdopting the Senate's budget resolutionA budget resolution does not go to the President. This one let committees write a later bill that could pass by a simple majority.
52–48Concurrent Resolution Agreed to52 yes0 did not vote48 noRepublicans: 52 yes, 1 no. Democrats: 0 yes, 45 no. Independents: 0 yes, 2 no.The clerk recorded this vote as “On the Concurrent Resolution S.Con.Res. 7”.Who said whatWe chose these 6 statements to show the main arguments members made. They come from 2 debates on Feb 20, 2025.
- A family detention center in Dilley, Texas, is set to reopen
The private prison company CoreCivic said it had reached an agreement with the city of Dilley and ICE to reopen the South Texas Family Residential Center. A company spokesperson said it expected to hold families there. The Biden administration had stopped detaining families and closed the center in 2024. CoreCivic said it expected $180 million a year in revenue from it.
- ICE arrests Mahmoud Khalil, a green-card holder who led Columbia protests
ICE officers arrested Khalil, a recent Columbia University graduate student who had negotiated for pro-Palestinian protesters, in the lobby of his apartment building and moved him to a detention center in Louisiana. He is a lawful permanent resident. DHS said he had "led activities aligned to Hamas," and Trump said his arrest was the first of many. On March 10, a federal judge barred his deportation while the court considered his case.
- Senate and House floors · Floor speeches, a unanimous-consent request on S.Res. 136, and Sen. Cory Booker's 25-hour speech
Members argue over the flights to El Salvador and the courts
On March 11, House Republicans in the Border Security Caucus held a special order hour on the drop in border crossings and the rise in ICE arrests. After the March 15 flights to El Salvador, Trump called for Judge Boasberg's impeachment. On March 25, Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL) asked the Senate to pass S.Res. 136, which said the executive branch must obey court orders. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) asked to add the word "lawful" and listed an order to "stop deporting foreign terrorists" among judges' overreach. Durbin objected to Grassley's change, and the resolution did not pass. On the evening of March 31, Sen. Cory Booker (D-NJ) began a speech that lasted more than 25 hours, by his own count in the Record. He read news accounts of Abrego Garcia's case and of Venezuelans sent to CECOT.
Who said whatWe chose these 9 statements to show the main arguments members made. They come from 5 debates between Mar 11 and 31, 2025.
- Trump invokes the Alien Enemies Act, and about 250 men are flown to El Salvador
Trump's proclamation used the Alien Enemies Act against Tren de Aragua, the first use of the law since World War II. That evening, U.S. District Judge James Boasberg blocked deportations under it and ordered any planes already in the air to turn around. The government said the order came too late because the planes had left U.S. territory. El Salvador said 238 members of Tren de Aragua and 23 members of the MS-13 gang had arrived and would be held in its CECOT prison for a year. Lawyers for the men said they had no hearing to contest the gang label.
- The government says it deported Kilmar Abrego Garcia because of an "administrative error"
In a court filing, the government said Abrego Garcia, a Salvadoran man living in Maryland, was sent to El Salvador on March 15 "because of an administrative error," although ICE knew of a 2019 immigration court order that barred sending him there. He had been arrested on March 12. The government said he was a member of MS-13, citing an informant at a 2019 hearing. His lawyers denied it and said he had no criminal convictions.
All House and Senate statements in this period that mentioned ICE or deportation