Reference · September 2026
A Dictionary of Congressional Record Formatting Problems
A running catalogue of the typos, printing errors and layout conventions that make the Record difficult to parse.
The Congressional Record is the official transcript of House and Senate floor proceedings, typeset and published by the Government Printing Office (GPO). It has been produced since 1873. It is structured, and it is laid out in a particular typeset format dictated by GPO. That format covers page structure, headings, speaker bylines, page markings, paragraph indentation, and more. However, there is a surprising amount of variation in the formatting: some of it is intentional, but much of it is errors made by GPO when setting the overnight daily edition.
This catalogue is in two parts, split along that line.
- Part I is errors: GPO printed something wrong, and it would be wrong to a human reader too.
- Part II is variation in formatting, including uncommon cases and similar formatting that is easy to confuse when parsing.
Every entry gives the source excerpt as published, with the defect marked, and the file and line number so it can be checked. Each entry states what a generic parser might struggle with, and what our parser does. Counts, where they appear, are from our sample of days from 2024 through 2026, roughly 32,000 pages.
Several parsers already exist for the Record. The most widely used open-source one is congressional-record, which grew out of the Sunlight Foundation’s Capitol Words project. It was written by Nicholas Judd, Dan Drinkard, Jeremy Carbaugh and Lindsay Young, who all worked at or with the Sunlight Foundation, a nonprofit that advocated for government transparency from 2006 until it closed in 2020. A second source is a dataset, Congressional Record for the 43rd–114th Congresses, which covers 1873 to 2017. It was built by the economists Matthew Gentzkow of Stanford University, Jesse Shapiro, then of Brown University, and Matt Taddy, then of the University of Chicago Booth School of Business, and is distributed by Stanford Libraries. A third is ProPublica’s Capitol Words parser. ProPublica, a nonprofit newsroom, took over Capitol Words from the Sunlight Foundation in 2016. Our parser aims to improve on these in various ways we have documented elsewhere, including being robust to all of the errors and variations listed in the dictionary below.
Part I
Printing Errors
This section covers GPO printing mistakes. A human reader would call each one a
typo.
Bylines
Printing Error 1
Typo · Byline
A speaker's surname printed without capitals
Description
When a Member begins to speak on the floor, the Record opens their statement
with a byline in the following format: an honorific, the surname in all capital letters, possibly a state to help with disambiguation (if two members share the same surname), and a
period. An example of this standard format is shown below.
Mr. PALAZZO. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to remind the American people
that today marks President Biden's one year in office and 365 days of
his disastrous failure at our southern border.
Occasionally, GPO makes an error and the byline uses title case
rather than all capital letters. One example comes from a 2022 statement by Steven Palazzo. As printed, his surname is in title case rather than all capital letters.
Mr. Palazzo. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to remind the American people
that today marks President Biden's one year in office and 365 days of
his disastrous failure at our southern border.
Title case is also how the Record names people who are not speaking,
which it does constantly. Three kinds recur.
1. A nominee named before the description
Nomination and confirmation business opens by naming the nominee,
then describes them in the third person. The name is a private
citizen's, and the sentence that follows is about them rather than
spoken by them.
What that really means: We don't like windmills. We don't like to
look at them in Boston Harbor. We don't like offshore wind. We want
windmills built in Oklahoma, and you guys just ship us our electricity
so we can flick on the light.
Ms. Laura Daniels Davis. She has been nominated to be Assistant
Secretary for the Office of Land and Minerals Management. She is
currently in her role already with DOI. In her role in DOI, she has
already made the change that routine permitting decisions that are
typically made in the field to expedite the process of making permits,
those have all been pulled up to her desk in Washington, DC, where they
have slowed down dramatically.
2. A tribute naming its subject
Tributes and memorials open on the person being honoured. The
honorific is real, the name is real, and the person is not a Member
and is not speaking. Note that in this example there is no
end-of-sentence punctuation after the name, unlike a speaker byline.
Mr. Speaker, I rise today in support of H.R. 700, to designate the
facility of the United States Postal Service located at 303 East
Mississippi Avenue in Elwood, Illinois, as the ``Lawrence M. `Larry'
Walsh Sr. Post Office.''
Mr. Larry Walsh Sr. was an American farmer, public servant, and
dedicated member of the Will County community. In 1970, he began his
career in public service as a member of the Elwood School Board. He was
then elected as Jackson Township Supervisor in 1973, where he served
until December 2004. Mr. Walsh also served on the Will County Board in
1974 and 1992.
3. A name standing alone in a list
Appointments to commissions and delegations print one name per line,
each with a state and a closing period and nothing after it. The
names are in title case, not capitals, so the line has the same form
as a miscased title-case byline. The Chair's announcement sits above
the list, so the names are indented as body text.
75, the Chair, on behalf of the President pro tempore, upon the
recommendation of the Republican Leader, appoints the following
individuals to the United States Commission on International Religious
Freedom:
Mr. Abraham Cooper of California.
Mr. Eric M. Ueland of Oregon.
____________________
Printing Error 2
Typo · Byline
A comma where the byline's period belongs
Description
A byline closes with a period, and everything after that period is
the speech. The period is the boundary marker: it is what separates
the Member's name from the first words of their statement. When a comma
is set instead, the name reads as the opening clause of the Member's
own sentence and nothing marks where the turn begins. There are
sixteen of these in our sample of days from 2024 through 2026,
roughly 32,000 pages, and they are spread
across the House, the Senate and Extensions of Remarks.
An example of the standard format is shown below.
back the balance of my time.
Ms. JACKSON LEE. Mr. Speaker, I rise in strong support of H.R. 2020,
the ``Post-Disaster Assistance Online Accountability Act.''
The example below shows a typo where the period is a comma.
Representative Sheila Jackson Lee has just been yielded
time—the line above is the end of the previous Member's
turn—so a new turn genuinely begins here.
back the balance of my time.
Ms. JACKSON LEE, Mr. Speaker, I rise in strong support of H.R. 2020,
the ``Post-Disaster Assistance Online Accountability Act.''
The same typo appears in the Senate, where Senator Alex Padilla is
introducing a bill rather than debating one.
Indian Affairs.
Mr. PADILLA, Mr. President, I rise to introduce the Katimiin and
Ameekyaaraam Sacred Lands Act to place roughly 1,000 acres of sacred
lands currently under Federal ownership into trust for the benefit of
the Karuk Tribe.
And again in Extensions of Remarks, in a tribute submitted for the
Record rather than spoken on the floor.
Mr. COSTA, Madam Speaker, I rise today to honor Nhia Long Vang, a
Major in the Special Guerilla Unit (SGU) Secret War in Laos, a husband,
father, and a beloved community activist in the Central Valley.
When parsing, you can attempt to correct for these typos by looking
at what follows the comma. In our sample, all sixteen are followed
either by a form of address (Mr. Speaker,
Mr. President) or by standard floor language
(I rise, I yield, I ask). That
may not always be present.
Printing Error 3
Typo · Byline
A byline with a stray word appended to the surname
Description
A byline is an honorific, a surname in capitals, an optional state,
and a period. A stray word set in capitals between the surname and the
period keeps every one of those properties and changes who the line
appears to name.
An example of the standard format is shown below.
Mr. CLINE. Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may
consume.
Representative Ben Cline manages a technical-corrections bill under
ordinary Mr. CLINE. bylines throughout this page.
Midway through the debate the Record prints the word
MEMBER where the period belongs.
Mr. CLINE. Mr. Speaker, I ask unanimous consent that all Members may
have 5 legislative days in which to revise and extend their remarks and
to insert extraneous material on H.R. 3496.
The SPEAKER pro tempore. Is there objection to the request of the
gentleman from Virginia?
There was no objection.
Mr. CLINE MEMBER. Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may
consume.
Mr. Speaker, as was stated, this bill makes technical corrections to
provisions of the code that contain statutory references to title 25 of
the United States Code.
The text satisfies all three properties of a byline: an honorific,
capitalised letters, and a terminal period. The name as it reads is
Mr. CLINE MEMBER; taken as printed, the surname is
MEMBER. However, no Member of Congress is named Cline
Member. The other Mr. CLINE. bylines on the same page
are printed correctly, so the defect is one statement out of several by
Cline. Printing errors like this can be checked by comparing the
scraped byline name to a list of congressional Members. Since no Member
is named Cline Member this check would fail, an error could be recorded
in a log along with an “Unknown” speaker label, and the typo
could be corrected during validation.
Printing Error 4
Typo · Byline
A speaker’s surname misspelled in the byline
Description
A byline prints the Member’s surname in capitals. Sometimes
GPO misspells the surname. In the .htm files from 2020
to 2026 we found 47 bylines, out of about 195,000, with a misspelled
surname. Most are one or two letters off, such as
Ms. KLOBUCHER. for Klobuchar,
Mr. CASSSIDY. for Cassidy, and
Mr. CRDENAS. for Cárdenas, with the
Á dropped. An example of the
standard format is shown below.
Mr. LEVIN of Michigan. Mr. Speaker, I yield 1 minute to the gentleman
from the Northern Mariana Islands (Mr. Sablan), a member of the
Committee on Education and Labor and my esteemed colleague.
Mr. SABLAN. Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of H.R. 447.
Apprenticeships are well recognized as a way to help local economies
grow by providing career opportunities for young people. However, the
current national apprenticeship system does not adequately support the
creation of apprenticeships in the Marianas and other insular areas.
A month later, in the debate on the American Rescue Plan, the same
Member’s byline is printed without the L.
Instead, we have this political payoff, which leaves Americans
behind, while Democrats demand they foot the bill for it.
I urge my colleagues to vote no.
Mr. SABAN. Mr. Speaker, One year ago, the bottom fell out for the
people of the Northern Mariana Islands. Our tourism-dependent economy
suddenly had no tourists. Businesses began closing. People were laid
off. Schools closed. And government revenues plunged.
We were fortunate that, as islands with few access points, we could
In some instances the printed name bears little resemblance to the
Member’s name. On 16 January 2020 the Record prints the byline
Mr. CRAWLEY. At that time no Member of the House or
Senate had the surname Crawley. The closest name is Joseph Crowley, a
Representative from New York who left the House in January 2019. The
statement is likely meant to be attributed to Senator Chuck Grassley. The
Senator thanks the staff “who work for the people of
Iowa” and names “Kolan Davis, my Finance Committee staff
director.” At the time Grassley, of Iowa, chaired the Senate
Finance Committee, and Kolan Davis was his staff director.
h.r. 5430
Mr. CRAWLEY. Mr. President, it is no secret around here that staff
work is key to any Senator's success. It often goes unnoticed and
unthanked, but today, as the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement
Implementation Act passes Congress, I would like to express my
appreciation to the many Senate staff who work for the people of Iowa
and the entire country.
Foremost among them are Kolan Davis, my Finance Committee staff
director and longtime advisor of 35 years; Jeff Wrase, my deputy staff
director; and Nasim Fussell, my chief international trade counsel on
As described elsewhere in this dictionary, GPO also publishes a
metadata file, mods.xml, for each day of the Record. For each topic,
mods.xml lists the Members who speak about that topic, but it does
not include the text of their statements. We checked mods.xml for
the 47 surname misspellings described above. For 19 of them,
mods.xml lists the Member with the surname spelled correctly. For the
other 28, mods.xml omits the Member altogether. It never repeats the
misspelling.
A misspelled surname causes problems for any parser that attempts to
match printed bylines against a list of Members, such as the
Biographical Directory of the United States Congress. Because the
misspelled surname matches no Member, the full Member information
cannot be joined to enrich the statement. As discussed, mods.xml
cannot be used to fully solve this problem, since it sometimes omits
Members with misspelled surnames.
How our parser handles it
In our pipeline, a statement whose byline matches no Member is held
back from loading. During validation, an agent reads the statement
and identifies the Member from its content or, in Extensions of
Remarks, from the heading, which prints the Member’s full
name. The agent then loads the statement under that Member and
writes a note explaining the correction. For the Sablan example, our
agent’s note reads: “GPO misprinted the byline
‘Mr. SABAN.’ for Sablan … speech is about the
Northern Mariana Islands.” These notes are stored in our
database so that every correction can be audited.
Printing Error 5
Typo · Byline
A placeholder printed instead of the speaker’s name
Description
On most days the Senate is in session, a Senator asks permission for
the Senate’s committees to meet during the session, and the
Record prints the request under that Senator’s byline. In a
sample of data from 2020 to 2026, we found two of these requests
where the byline reads Mr. XXX., a placeholder
that was never replaced with the Senator’s name. An example of
the standard format is shown below.
AUTHORITY FOR COMMITTEES TO MEET
Mr. PORTMAN. Mr. President, I have 8 requests for committees to meet
during today's session of the Senate. They have the approval of the
Majority and Minority leaders.
The next day, a similar request is printed with XXX in
place of the Senator’s name.
AUTHORITY FOR COMMITTEES TO MEET
Mr. XXX. Mr. President, I have 5 requests for committees to meet
during today's session of the Senate. They have the approval of the
Majority and Minority leaders.
Mr. XXX. has the same format as a byline: an
honorific, a word in capitals where the surname belongs, and a
period. A parser that finds bylines by their format therefore reads
it as a byline, with XXX as the speaker’s surname. The problem
appears when the parser matches the surname against a list of
Members: no Member is named XXX, so the match fails. Nothing in the
printed text says which Senator made the request, and mods.xml lists
no Members for the topic. So unlike a misspelled surname, where the
surrounding text can identify the Member, here there is no way to
determine who the speaker was.
How our parser handles it
Our parsing separates procedural content from substantive
statements, and we load only the substantive statements. Requests
for committees to meet are procedural, so these two bylines do not
affect our data.
Headings
Printing Error 6
Layout · Heading
A heading printed with no blank line above or below it
Description
By GPO typesetting rules a heading has at least one blank space above
and below it. However, occasionally a heading is printed with no
blank line above it and none below.
An example of the standard format is shown below.
Mr. Speaker, I congratulate their team and thank them for sharing
Iowa's story.
Recognizing and Celebrating Adam Zeithamel
Mrs. MILLER-MEEKS. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize and
An example of this misprinted title layout is the page below from
November 1, 2023. Representative Mariannette Miller-Meeks entered
several tributes in sequence. The first four headings have blank
lines above and below them. The fifth,
Congratulating Dennis Lauver, has neither: it follows
immediately on the last line of the Iowa women's basketball remarks,
and her byline follows immediately on the next line.
Mr. Speaker, I thank Coach Bluder for her inspiring leadership behind
this event, and I congratulate the entire University of Iowa women's
basketball team on this incredible milestone. Go Hawks.
Congratulating Dennis Lauver
Mrs. MILLER-MEEKS. Mr. Speaker, I congratulate Dennis Lauver with
Coldwell Banker Howes & Jefferies in Clinton, Iowa, for his 1-year
appointment to the National Association of Realtors Federal Taxation
Committee.
Congratulations, Dennis.
This line keeps none of the three properties that mark a heading: it
is not centered, it has no blank line above it, and it has no blank
line below it. This case is extremely difficult to account for using deterministic
parsing rules without introducing false positives: a non-heading line
like statement text, a committee name, or a bill title mentioned in
remarks as a heading.
How our parser handles it
We handle it in post-parsing validation.
Printing Error 7
Typo · Heading
A heading printed entirely in lowercase
Description
Congressional Record headings are printed in capitals or in title
case. Occasionally, GPO makes an error and a heading is printed
entirely in lowercase. We found roughly forty of these in our sample
of days from 2024 through 2026.
An example is Representative Earl L. “Buddy” Carter's
Extensions of Remarks file of 14 May 2026 (Extensions of Remarks are
written statements entered into the Record). Each remark had its own
heading. Four of the twenty-one are in lowercase. Two correctly
printed headings above them are shown for comparison.
RECOGNIZING GRIFF LYNCH
Mr. CARTER of Georgia. Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize Griff
Lynch for his outstanding service as president and CEO of the Georgia
Ports Authority.
Honoring Life and Legacy of Ted Turner
Mr. CARTER of Georgia. Madam Speaker, I rise today to honor the life
and the legacy of Ted Turner, the founder of CNN and a former Savannah
resident.
recognizing the savannah country day school
Mr. CARTER of Georgia. Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize the
Savannah Country Day School faculty, staff, and parents' association.
recognizing the port of brunswick
Mr. CARTER of Georgia. Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize the
Port of Brunswick for their second year in a row as the busiest
automotive port in the country.
Apart from the casing, these four headings are printed correctly. Each
is centered, has a blank line above and below, ends without
punctuation, and is followed by a byline, the same as the seventeen
correct headings in the file. This can make lowercase title detection
and parsing challenging.
How our parser handles it
Our parser first tests each candidate line
for all capitals or title case, and these lines fail both tests. It
then falls back to the layout: a line indented at least six spaces,
with a blank line above and below, no sentence-ending punctuation, and
a byline on the next line is accepted as a heading whatever its
casing. All four lowercase headings on this page are found this way. A
later step converts them to title case, so
recognizing the savannah country day school is stored as
Recognizing the Savannah Country Day School.
Printing Error 8
Typo · Heading
A heading with a word misspelled
Description
Sometimes GPO misspells a title. In a small sample from April 2022,
we found four of the 901 titles are misspelled. Several examples
are provided below. One indication the title is misspelled is that
the misspelled word is often also used in the title's associated
statement text, but with a correct spelling. This indicates the
misspelled title word is not simply an alternative spelling or an
acronym.
The first example is from Senator Rand Paul’s tribute to a
Kentucky museum. Here two letters are transposed, so
MUSEUM is spelled as MUSUEM.
WEST KENTUCKY VETERAN AND PATRIOT MUSUEM
Mr. PAUL. Mr. President, stories of the past and the
memorabilia and photos that often accompany them serve many important
purposes in our culture. They can entertain us and provoke laughter and
joy. They can reinforce the values that were important to our parents
and grandparents. And they can teach difficult or even painful lessons
from our history. The West Kentucky Veteran and Patriot Museum, now
celebrating its 10th year, is a place where such stories can be
The second example is from Representative Virginia Foxx of North
Carolina, on April 28, 2022. The first letter of the first word is
dropped, leaving outhern for Southern.
outhern Border Catastrophe Continues
Ms. FOXX. Madam Speaker, our southern border is under siege and
President Biden is asleep at the wheel.
Over 40 illegal aliens on the terror watch list have been arrested at
the southern border since President Biden took office.
Two other examples are Representative Terri Sewell of Alabama, on
April 29, 2022, where EXTRAODINARY is printed for
EXTRAORDINARY, and Representative Emanuel Cleaver of
Missouri, on April 18, 2022, where ADVANCE is printed
for ADVANCED in the name of Metropolitan Community
College's Advanced Technical Skills Institute.
How our parser handles it
In our data pipeline we have a step that recases titles. Titles
are printed in the Congressional Record in a variety of casings, including all capitals, title
case, and all lowercase. We standardize to title case, the normal
casing for titles, because it is easier to read than the other
forms. During that step we leave misspellings in place. That lets
us check the recased title character by character against the
source as a gaurdrail. This ensures that during recasing the model cannot change the title. A post-processing
agent then fixes any misspellings via our ledger, giving us an auditable log of any diffs.
Punctuation and paragraphs
Printing Error 9
Typo · Punctuation
A period where a comma belongs, after a form of address
Description
This is Printing Error 2 in reverse. There, a byline's period was set as a
comma; here, a comma inside an ordinary sentence is set as a period.
Mr. Speaker is how a Member addresses the presiding
officer of the House. House rules require Members to address the
chair rather than one another, so a statement typically opens with
that address and a comma, then the first words of the statement. In
the Senate the equivalent is
Mr./Mrs./Miss President.
An example of the standard format is shown below.
Trustee and has sung in the choir.
Mr. Speaker, please join me in recognizing Mrs. McKinney for her
dedication to St. Thomas United Methodist Church.
The example below shows a typo where the comma is a period. This is
the closing paragraph of a tribute by Representative Mike Rogers of
Alabama—not the start of anyone's statement. The lowercase
please immediately after is the giveaway that no new
sentence was intended.
Trustee and has sung in the choir.
Mr. Speaker. please join me in recognizing Mrs. McKinney for her
dedication to St. Thomas United Methodist Church.
When building a parser, you must be careful about this. Without a
capitalisation requirement, and without checking the name against a
known list of Members or against mods.xml as some
parsers do, Mr. Speaker. could be identified as a byline
for a Member named Speaker. An ordinary byline is compared below, so
the confusion is visible. Here the speaker is Representative Jared
Moskowitz.
Mr. MOSKOWITZ. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize Lori Baer, the
Executive Director of the Port Everglades Association and port industry
Printing Error 10
Typo · Punctuation
A paragraph that ends with no punctuation
Description
The Congressional Record uses standard English punctuation.
Occasionally GPO makes a typo and omits the closing mark at the end of
a paragraph of speech.
Representative Abigail Davis Spanberger's tribute to Mrs. Eileen
Thrall parses correctly in every other respect: the title is
Honoring Mrs. Eileen Thrall, the member is right, and the 286
words span pages E1036 to E1037. Only the period at the end of the
opening paragraph is missing.
HONORING MRS. EILEEN THRALL
HON. ABIGAIL DAVIS SPANBERGER
of virginia
in the house of representatives
Wednesday, November 1, 2023
Ms. SPANBERGER. Mr. Speaker, I rise to congratulate Mrs. Eileen
Thrall on being named Dumfries, Virginia's 2023 Living Legend by Mayor
Derrick Wood
For years, Eileen has served as an exemplary member of the Dumfries
community through her work as a reporter for Potomac News, where she
authored the widely enjoyed Dumfries Community Column.
How our parser handles it
Parse boundaries come from bylines, headings, and layout, not from
whether a paragraph has a period. The typo is therefore kept in the
statement of whoever the parser has identified as the current speaker.
Printing Error 11
Layout · Paragraph
A wrapped line indented as if it began a paragraph
Description
By GPO typesetting rules a paragraph opens with a two-space indent, and
the lines that continue it are adjusted flush left. Paragraphs are not
separated by a blank line, the two-space indent is the only marker of
where a paragraph begins. Occasionally GPO makes a typo and a
continuation line is indented as well, so a line in the middle of a
sentence reads as the start of a new paragraph. An example of the
standard format is shown below, from a tribute by Representative Jared
Moskowitz. The statement has three paragraphs: each opens at indent 2,
and the lines that continue each paragraph are adjusted flush left.
Mr. MOSKOWITZ. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize Lori Baer, the
Executive Director of the Port Everglades Association and port industry
veteran, for her three decades of contributions to the industry.
Lori gained her port experience in the public and private sectors,
holding various distinguished roles. At AECOM, a global engineering and
consulting firm, she held the positions of Vice President and Ports and
Marine Lead for the Americas. She also served as Executive Director of
the Port of Palm Beach. Additionally, she has performed in senior
management positions at the Port of Miami and the Western Hemisphere-
wide American Association of Port Authorities. Lori has dedicated her
career to developing an unmatched expertise in the port industry, which
has served her communities domestically and internationally.
Mr. Speaker, I ask that you join me in recognizing the Executive
Director of the Port Everglades Association, Lori Baer, for her
outstanding career and contributions to the ports of the Western
Hemisphere and Florida's 23rd Congressional District.
An example of this typo appears in Representative Rosa DeLauro's tribute to
Doris “Deb” Biesterfeld Townshend of 6 November 2023. Her
byline opens the statement correctly at indent 2. Continuation lines
that should have been adjusted flush left are indented instead: three
at indent 3 and a fourth at indent 2, none of which begins a new
paragraph. As a side note, one of the mis-indented lines also drops
the space after the period in Avenue.The, so there are
actually two separate defects presented in this example.
Ms. DeLAURO. Mr. Speaker, today, family, friends, and community
leaders will gather to
remember one of the City of New Haven's greatest treasures, Doris
``Deb'' Biesterfeld Townshend, who we lost in September of 2020. At the
age of 98, she had lived a full life and passed peacefully at her
cherished, historic Victorian home, known as Raynham, on Townsend
Avenue.The Townshend's family line in New Haven stretches back to
1739, when Jeremiah Townsend of Boston, first settled there. Deb met
When thinking about displaying parsed Congressional Record statements,
one may want to improve readability beyond the standard GPO
typesetting by introducing a blank line between paragraphs in the
frontend UI display. This typo introduces substantial challenges in
that approach, because indentation is the only way to indicate when a
new paragraph starts: the statement breaks into a new paragraph at
Avenue., mid-address.
How our parser handles it
We handle this case in post-processing. A validation flags any
paragraph that ends without closing punctuation, which is what a typo
of this kind leaves behind since each new indentation generates a new
paragraph without ever having ended the previous one. An AI agent
checks each flagged statement in the validation, rereads the source
file, and repairs the text.
Page structure
Printing Error 12
Typo · Header block
Stray characters and misspellings in the Extensions header
Description
Every Extensions of Remarks page opens with the same header block:
the Member in capitals, the state, the chamber, and the date. In the
standard format the state and chamber lines are set in lowercase. We
found cases where the state was misspelled.
An example of the standard format is shown below.
HON. <MEMBER NAME>
of <state>
in the house of representatives
The example below shows Illinois with a hyphen printed before the
state name, in a tribute by Representative Danny K. Davis.
HON. DANNY K. DAVIS
of -illinois
in the house of representatives
Wednesday, January 12, 2022
Mr. DANNY K. DAVIS of Illinois. Madam Speaker, life is precious, even
if you live it for only a brief period of time. When you are blessed to
live 110 years, one hundred and ten productive years, and be in
relatively good health, good enough to talk several minutes with a
Congressman who called your daughter to get some information, you are
truly blessed.
The example below shows Connecticut misspelled, in a tribute by
Representative Rosa DeLauro.
HON. ROSA L. DeLAURO
of connecticcut
in the house of representatives
Monday, November 6, 2023
Ms. DeLAURO. Mr. Speaker, today, family, friends, and community
leaders will gather to
remember one of the City of New Haven's greatest treasures, Doris
``Deb'' Biesterfeld Townshend, who we lost in September of 2020. At the
age of 98, she had lived a full life and passed peacefully at her
cherished, historic Victorian home, known as Raynham, on Townsend
Avenue.
The example below shows Pennsylvania misspelled, in a tribute by
Representative Guy Reschenthaler.
HON. GUY RESCHENTHALER
of p0ennsylvania
in the house of representatives
Friday, November 17, 2023
Mr. RESCHENTHALER. Mr. Speaker, I rise to congratulate Somerset Area
School District for being recognized by the National Association of
Music Merchants (NAMM) Foundation as one of the best communities for
music education in 2023.
The NAMM Foundation celebrates schools and school districts by
recognizing their ability to train and educate the next generation of
musicians.
The header block sits above the first byline on the page and duplicates
information available elsewhere: the Member is named on the byline
below, and a Member's state is a matter of record. For these reasons,
most parsers discard the header when parsing, so this printing error
has little practical significance.
Printing Error 13
Typo · Page identity
A page published with no page number
Description
GPO prints a page number in the header of each Congressional Record
.htm file, and reprints it throughout the file if the
statement runs more than one page. The same page number also appears
in the file name.
An example of the standard format is shown below.
[Congressional Record Volume 168, Number 84 (Tuesday, May 17, 2022)]
[House]
[Page H5076]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office
ANNOUNCEMENT BY THE SPEAKER PRO TEMPORE
The SPEAKER pro tempore. Proceedings will resume on questions
previously postponed.
In our sample of days from 2024 through 2026, we found that on
nineteen House statement files on 17 May 2022 the page number is
missing from both the file name and the file contents. The files are
named
CREC-2022-05-17-pt1-PgHnull.htm
through
CREC-2022-05-17-pt1-PgHnull-19.htm,
with the file name including the literal word
null where the number
belongs. The header reads [Page H] and stops
without identifying the page number, rather than a complete
identifier of the form [Page H5076].
[Congressional Record Volume 168, Number 84 (Tuesday, May 17, 2022)]
[House]
[Page H]
From the Congressional Record Online through the Government Publishing Office
DESIGNATION OF SPEAKER PRO TEMPORE
The SPEAKER pro tempore laid before the House the following
communication from the Speaker:
Washington, DC,
May 17, 2022.
I hereby appoint the Honorable Paul Tonko to act as Speaker
pro tempore on this day.
Nancy Pelosi,
Speaker of the House of Representatives.
# … statement continues …
This is an issue if in parsing you aim to associate statements with
their page numbers, since neither the file name nor the file contents
supplies one.
How our parser handles it
Because this case is rare, we intentionally fail when
the file name has null, the failure is logged, and the
file is fixed manually in post-processing.
Printing Error 14
Typo · Heading
Null characters around a heading
Description
GPO’s HTML for a page sometimes contains null bytes, a
character that has no printed form. In 2022, seven House and Senate
pages contain null bytes at or near a heading. On five of those
pages, GPO’s metadata file for the day, mods.xml,
gives the page a garbled title.
The example below is from Representative Abigail Spanberger’s
one-minute speech of March 16, 2022, recognizing the marathon runner
Keira D’Amato. Line 12 contains 816 null bytes followed by the
letter q. Line 14 contains the heading, with 23 null bytes before it
and 352 after, then a second copy of the heading missing its first
letter. GPO’s mods.xml gives the page the title
“q”.
[␀ × 816]q
[␀ × 23]RECOGNIZING KEIRA D'AMATO[␀ × 352]ECOGNIZING KEIRA D'AMATO
(Ms. SPANBERGER asked and was given permission to address the House
for 1 minute and to revise and extend her remarks.)
Ms. SPANBERGER. Madam Speaker, I stand here to recognize the
incredible achievement of Midlothian resident Keira D'Amato.
We tested the two parsers named in the introduction that can be run
on a 2022 file: the Sunlight Foundation’s congressional-record
and ProPublica’s Capitol Words. The Stanford dataset ends in
2017. Both parsers title this speech “q”, because both
take a page’s title from mods.xml. Capitol Words
also keeps the 352 null bytes in the text of the speech.
How our parser handles it
Our parser takes titles from the page itself rather than from
mods.xml. Before we handled null bytes, our parser did
not recognize the heading on line 14. It filed the speech under the
debate on the previous page. After parsing, our pipeline stores
statements in Postgres, which cannot store a null character. For that
reason our pipeline failed to load any statement whose title or text
contained one. We now remove null bytes as we read each file, turning
those in front of a heading back into the spaces that center it. A
daily validation flags any published statement whose page still
carries such a block, so a review agent checks its title.
Metadata
Printing Error 15
Error · Metadata
The day’s metadata does not contain a statement’s speaker
Description
In addition to the .htm and PDF files it publishes for
each statement, GPO also publishes one metadata file,
mods.xml, for each day of the Record. It lists every
statement file of that day with a title, a page range, and the Members
who spoke in it. It also contains a bioGuide ID for each of those
Members, the identifier the Biographical Directory of the United
States Congress assigns them, which stays the same across Congresses
and so names a Member unambiguously however the Record prints them.
In some cases we found that the byline misspells a Member's surname
and mods.xml lists no Member for that statement.
An example of the standard format is shown below. Representative Raja
Krishnamoorthi entered a tribute on 28 January 2022, and the byline
spells his surname as GPO’s own roster spells it.
RECOGNIZING DR. NASIR AHMED
HON. RAJA KRISHNAMOORTHI
of illinois
in the house of representatives
Friday, January 28, 2022
Mr. KRISHNAMOORTHI. Madam Speaker, today I wish to recognize the
seminal contributions of Dr. Nasir Ahmed in the field of computer
The snippet from the mods.xml for this statement is
shown below. It names him and gives his bioGuide ID.
<extension>
<searchTitle>RECOGNIZING DR. NASIR AHMED; Congressional Record Vol. 168, No. 18</searchTitle>
<granuleClass>EXTENSIONS</granuleClass>
<accessId>CREC-2022-01-28-pt1-PgE73-4</accessId>
<subGranuleClass>RECOGNIZING</subGranuleClass>
<pagePrefix>E</pagePrefix>
<bookNumber>1</bookNumber>
<chamber>HOUSE</chamber>
<granuleDate>2022-01-28</granuleDate>
<congMember authorityId="2325" bioGuideId="K000391" chamber="H"
congress="117" party="D" role="SPEAKING" state="IL">
<name type="parsed">Mr. KRISHNAMOORTHI</name>
<name type="authority-fnf">Raja Krishnamoorthi</name>
<name type="authority-lnf">Krishnamoorthi, Raja</name>
</congMember>
</extension>
The example below shows a tribute by the same Member ten weeks later,
where the byline misspells his surname.
OBSERVING DISTRACTED DRIVING AWARENESS MONTH
HON. RAJA KRISHNAMOORTHI
of illinois
in the house of representatives
Monday, April 11, 2022
Mr. KIRSHNAMOORTHI. Madam Speaker, I rise today to join thousands of
organizations and individuals around the country in observation of
The snippet from the mods.xml for this statement is
shown below. It contains no congMember element, likely
because of the misspelling.
<extension>
<searchTitle>OBSERVING DISTRACTED DRIVING AWARENESS MONTH; Congressional Record Vol. 168, No. 63</searchTitle>
<granuleClass>EXTENSIONS</granuleClass>
<accessId>CREC-2022-04-11-pt1-PgE379-3</accessId>
<subGranuleClass>ALLOTHER</subGranuleClass>
<pagePrefix>E</pagePrefix>
<bookNumber>1</bookNumber>
<chamber>HOUSE</chamber>
<granuleDate>2022-04-11</granuleDate>
</extension>
We found similar cases in a number of other files spread across our
sample, each one a misprinted byline whose statement has no
congMember element in that day's
mods.xml. A
few examples are below.
-
Representative Nydia Velazquez's surname was printed as
Ms. VALAZQUEZ.
-
Representative Betty McCollum's surname was printed as
Ms. McCULLUM.
-
Representative Guy Reschenthaler's surname was printed as
Mr. RENSCHENTHALER.
-
Representative James Clyburn's surname was printed as
Mr. CLYBRUN.
-
Senator Catherine Cortez Masto's surname was printed as
Ms. CORTEZ-MASTO, with a
hyphen the name does not have.
-
Representative Trent Kelly's state, rather than his surname, was
printed as
Mr. KELLY of Misissippi.
-
Representative Steven Palazzo's and Representative Henry Cuellar's
surnames were printed without all capitals, as
Mr. Palazzo and Mr. Cuellar, the error
catalogued in Printing Error 1.
We also found cases where the byline was spelled correctly but the
statement still has no congMember in that day's
mods.xml. Below is a tribute by Representative Matt Van Epps, whose
byline, header block and surname are all set correctly.
HONORING COLONEL BRENT LINDEMAN
HON. MATT VAN EPPS
of tennessee
in the house of representatives
Wednesday, March 18, 2026
Mr. VAN EPPS. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize Colonel Brent
Lindeman for his extraordinary service to our Nation and his steadfast
The snippet from the mods.xml for this statement is
shown below. It contains no congMember element.
<extension>
<searchTitle>HONORING COLONEL BRENT LINDEMAN; Congressional Record Vol. 172, No. 49</searchTitle>
<granuleClass>EXTENSIONS</granuleClass>
<accessId>CREC-2026-03-18-pt1-PgE229-4</accessId>
<subGranuleClass>HONORING</subGranuleClass>
<pagePrefix>E</pagePrefix>
<bookNumber>1</bookNumber>
<chamber>HOUSE</chamber>
<granuleDate>2026-03-18</granuleDate>
</extension>
We found seven statements in our sample that print Representative Van
Epps's byline but have no congMember for him in that
day's mods.xml.
In our sample we found nineteen statements that have a
Member’s byline but no Member in that day’s
mods.xml. Ten of those bylines are misprinted. The other
nine are printed correctly.
A missing
congMember element is an issue if a parser
takes the speaker from
mods.xml. Several well-known
Congressional Record parsers do this. The open-source
congressional-record
parser reads the Member names from
mods.xml and matches
them against the page. ProPublica's
Capitol Words
parser also takes speaker names from
mods.xml. When
mods.xml lists no Member for the statement, those parsers
have no speaker.
How our parser handles it
We do not use mods.xml. We instead parse
the byline directly from the HTML.
Parsing the byline ourselves means a misspelled surname still has to
be resolved. We match the surname printed in the byline against a
database of Members of Congress, using the state and the date of the
statement to disambiguate Members who share a surname. A misspelling
such as KIRSHNAMOORTHI matches no Member, so the
statement is held back from storage in our database, which powers
our frontend UI, and the failure is recorded.
A validation then reports every statement left without a Member, and
an AI agent rereads the source file and repairs the attribution in
post-processing.
Printing Error 16
Error · Metadata
An issue published under the wrong number
Description
Congress works in yearly terms called sessions. The Congressional
Record gives each session its own volume and numbers that
volume’s issues from No. 1. Each day Congress meets gets the
next issue number in that volume. A new session usually opens on
January 3. In most years, Congress formally closes the old session
on January 3 and opens the new one the same day. The Record then
prints two issues dated January 3: the last issue of the old volume
and the first issue of the new one.
On January 3, 2014, those were Volume 159, No. 186 and Volume 160,
No. 1. GovInfo’s files mistakenly label the Volume 159 issue
as Number 1, so GovInfo lists two issues numbered 1 on January 3,
2014, one in each volume. Congress.gov’s list of issues
mistakenly gives it a third number, No. 185. The front page of the
Record itself correctly prints the Volume 159 issue as No. 186. We
only found one instance of this typo.
Congress.gov’s list (our pre-loaded number)
185
Printed Record
186 (correct)
How our parser handles it
Before loading a day’s files, our download step checks them
against the issue it expects. This is done using the volume and
issue number GovInfo records for each issue which is compared
against the volume and issue number we have pre-loaded for that
day, which comes from Congress.gov’s list of issues.
Our pipeline threw an error on January 3, 2014 because the two
numbers did not match. We then manually corrected the issue number
in our pre-loaded data and reran the day.
Separators
Printing Error 17
Layout · Separator
A section divider printed as F_____
Description
GPO uses a centered line of underscores as a visual rule to help
differentiate headings from content. This style of separation
appears in various places throughout the Record, such as the
Senate's Additional Statements section, Extensions of Remarks, and
at the close of some House and Senate pages.
Occasionally, GPO misprints the divider and it appears in the
.htm files as the literal text F_____: a
capital F followed by five underscores. In our sample we have
observed just two cases of this printing error. The likeliest
explanation is a decorative print rule that did not survive
conversion to plain text. An example of the standard format is
shown below.
ADDITIONAL STATEMENTS
______
TRIBUTE TO DALE DANNEWITZ
Mr. CRAMER. Madam President, it is an honor to recognize the
On 31 July 2024 the divider printed as F_____ twice on
the same Additional Statements page: before Senator Kevin Cramer's
tribute to Dale Dannewitz, and again after that tribute closed,
before Senator Jon Tester's tribute to Katharine Berkoff.
ADDITIONAL STATEMENTS
F_____
TRIBUTE TO DALE DANNEWITZ
Mr. CRAMER. Madam President, it is an honor to recognize the
nearly half century of distinguished service of a remarkable North
Dakotan who retired this year.
It is people like Dale Dannewitz who have ensured the safe movement
of products and commodities across the continent by rail. On behalf of
all North Dakotans, I thank him for his service and congratulate him on
his well-earned retirement. May you enjoy many years of health and
happiness in the future.
F_____
TRIBUTE TO KATHARINE BERKOFF
Mr. TESTER. Madam President, I rise today to recognize an
outstanding Montanan …
A parser that strips only lines made of underscores will miss
F_____, because the line begins with a letter. The token
then rides through as text. It does not match title detection, so it
is stored as the last line of the tribute above it. In this file that
is the closing of Cramer's statement.
How our parser handles it
Across the statements we loaded, the form appeared twice, both on
this one page. We removed those two tokens by hand and did not change
the pipeline for a case that rare. We re-scan periodically.
Files
Printing Error 18
Error · Files
Duplicate files
Description
GovInfo publishes each day of the Record as a set of files, one for
each heading, such as a debate or a speech. The Record numbers its
pages consecutively through each session of Congress, with a letter
for each section: H for the House, S for the Senate, E for
Extensions of Remarks, and D for the Daily Digest. Each file is
named for the page where its heading starts, so
PgH3714.htm starts on House page 3,714 of that
session. When more than one heading starts on the same page, each
later file adds a number: PgH3714-2.htm,
PgH3714-3.htm.
We found 182 files on three days that are byte-for-byte copies of
another file from the same day: 170 on May 24, 2010, and six Daily
Digest pages each on April 28, 2015, and January 8, 2026. For
example, on May 24, 2010, PgH3714-2.htm is a copy of
PgH3714.htm, a 1,225-word House debate.
How our parser handles it
Our parser processes every file for the day, so a duplicate file
produces duplicate statements. We remove duplicate statements before
loading them into our database. The process works like this:
- Our pipeline compares all of the day’s statements.
-
It looks for two statements in the same chamber that have the
same speaker and the same text, ignoring spacing and
capitalization, and are at least 10 words long. For each such
pair, it keeps the first statement and adds the second one’s
file name to the first one’s list of source files.
- It drops the second, duplicate statement.
-
It does not merge statements shorter than 10 words, because short
replies like “I object.” can be said more than once
in a debate. A duplicate file can therefore still add a duplicate
short statement. We use AI to help manually check for these cases
and remove them.
Printing Error 19
Error · Files
Malformed file names
Description
GovInfo publishes each day of the Record as a set of files, one for
each heading, such as a debate or a speech. The Record numbers its
pages consecutively through each session of Congress, with a letter
for each section: H for the House, S for the Senate, E for
Extensions of Remarks, and D for the Daily Digest. Each file is
named for the page where its heading starts, so
PgH3730.htm starts on House page 3,730 of that
session. When more than one heading starts on the same page, each
later file adds one number, as in PgH3730-2.htm and
PgH3730-3.htm.
In some cases, a file name adds more than one number. We found one
such case on May 24, 2010 (Volume 156, No. 79), where 154 file names
add a second or third number, such as PgH3730-9-2.htm
and PgH3730-2-2-2.htm. All 154 files are also
duplicates, as described in Printing Error 18. For example,
PgH3730-9-2.htm is a copy of
PgH3730-9.htm.
How our parser handles it
Our pipeline reads each file’s page from its name, keeping the
page and at most one added number. It therefore reads both
PgH3730-9-2.htm and PgH3730-9.htm as page
H3730-9.
One step of our pipeline sends each page to an AI model to find
where unanimous consent requests begin and end. Our AI provider
requires every request in a batch to have its own ID. Our pipeline
builds each request’s ID from the day, the page and the part of
the page being sent. Because PgH3730-9-2.htm and
PgH3730-9.htm were both read as page H3730-9, their
requests got the same ID. Our pipeline therefore failed when it
submitted that batch.
We went back and applied a fix in our download step, which now
deletes any file whose name adds more than one number and whose
bytes match another file from the same day.
Part II
Formatting Variations
Part I catalogued cases where GPO printed something wrong. This part
documents printing variations that, while not errors per se, can be
challenging for a parser if not designed carefully.
These variations include the rare honorific Miss,
surnames with lowercase letters inside them, hyphenated surnames, a middle initial printed inside the byline, a
two-word surname, headings whose
first line is not centered, titles that do not describe the debate
beneath them, editorial notes, page and time markers, and many more.
Bylines
Printing Variation 1
Variation · Honorific
Using Miss as an honorific
Description
When a Member begins to speak on the floor, the Record opens their
statement with a byline in the following format: an honorific, the
surname in all capital letters, and a period. The honorific is
almost always Mr., Ms. or
Mrs.. An example of this standard format is shown below.
Mr. PALAZZO. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to remind the American people
Occasionally the byline honorific is Miss.
Miss is not an abbreviation, so it has no period. In our
sample every such byline belongs to Resident Commissioner Jenniffer
González-Colón. An example is shown below.
from Puerto Rico (Miss Gonzalez-Colon).
Miss GONZALEZ-COLON. Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of the approval
in the House of the Senate amendment to H.R. 1192, the Puerto Rico
Recovery Accuracy in Disclosures Act of 2021.
The honorific counts in our sample are Mr. 29,680,
Ms. 6,438, Mrs. 2,799 and Miss
38, so the three common honorifics account for 99.9 percent of
bylines. A parser that accepts only those three honorifics will miss
every statement printed with Miss.
Printing Variation 2
Variation · Casing
A surname with lowercase letters inside it
Description
GPO typically prints a byline surname in all capitals. When the
ordinary spelling of a name includes a lowercase letter, that letter
stays lowercase and the rest of the surname is still printed in
capitals. Examples include McGOVERN, LaMALFA,
LaHOOD, McCLAIN, and
DesJARLAIS.
January 6 Wounds Must Heal
Mr. McGOVERN. Mr. Speaker, I thank the distinguished majority whip
for yielding me the time and for his commitment to justice and all
necessary to make this country a better place for everybody.
A parser that requires the surname to be all capitals will miss
every statement printed this way.
Printing Variation 3
Variation · Byline
A hyphenated surname
Description
GPO typically prints a byline surname as a single word in all
capitals. Some surnames are hyphenated: MILLER-MEEKS, GONZALEZ-COLON,
DIAZ-BALART. An example is Representative Mariannette
Miller-Meeks of Iowa.
Mrs. MILLER-MEEKS. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize the
achievements of several young ladies from my district.
A hyphenated surname can also include the lowercase letter from
Printing Variation 2. An example is Representative Sheila
Cherfilus-McCormick of Florida.
Cherfilus-McCormick), who is our newest Member of Congress.
Mrs. CHERFILUS-McCORMICK. Madam Speaker, I thank Mr. Diaz-Balart for
those kinds words and introduction.
A parser that does not allow a hyphen in the surname will miss
every statement printed this way. A parser that allows a hyphen
but requires the surname to be all capitals will miss names like
CHERFILUS-McCORMICK.
Printing Variation 4
Variation · Byline
A given name and middle initial printed in the byline
Description
A byline is typically an honorific, a surname in capitals, and a
period. When two Members share a surname, the Record adds
of <State> to tell them apart. An example is
Representative Adam Smith of Washington, who sat alongside Members
named Smith from Missouri, Nebraska and New Jersey.
Mr. SMITH of Washington. Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize and
thank Mr. Everett Coleman for his many years of service to the United
States Congress and congratulate him on his retirement.
When two Members share a surname and a state, the state cannot
differentiate them, so the given name and middle initial are
printed as well. Representative Carolyn B. Maloney of New York sat at
the same time as Representative Sean Patrick Maloney of New York. Both of their bylines are printed with their middle initial present. Carolyn B. Maloney's byline is shown below.
Mrs. CAROLYN B. MALONEY of New York. Madam Speaker, I rise to salute
Marina Letsios, a woman of exemplary work ethic and dedication to our
country.
To parse these bylines, a parser has to allow a middle initial,
including the period that follows it. Treating the first period on
the line as the end of the byline stops at
Mrs. CAROLYN B and misses the Member.
Printing Variation 5
Variation · Byline
A surname printed as two words
Description
A byline surname is typically one word. Some surnames are two:
JACKSON LEE, WASSERMAN SCHULTZ,
LEGER FERNANDEZ, VAN HOLLEN. An example is
Representative Sheila Jackson Lee of Texas.
Ms. JACKSON LEE. Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of S. 5230, the
``Help Find the Missing Act,'' also known as ``Billy's Law.''
A parser that assumes a surname is one word will not detect Members
whose surname is two words.
Headings
Printing Variation 6
Variation · Heading
A heading whose first line is not centered
Description
There are three properties that identify a heading: it is centered, it
has a blank line above it, and it has a blank line below it. As
explained elsewhere, GPO publishes each page of the Record in two
renditions: a PDF, which is the printed page as it was typeset, and an
.htm file, which is the format our pipeline uses for
parsing. The PDF is set in columns, like a newspaper, and in that
layout a heading is visually distinct because it is centered. All of
that formatting is reproduced in the .htm file, but that
file is plain text and is not set in columns, so the centering arrives
as spaces and a heading can appear at various offsets from the body
margin.
An example of the standard format is shown below. The heading is short
enough that space remains on both sides of the line, which is how
centering appears in the .htm file.
January 6 Wounds Must Heal
______
HON. <MEMBER NAME>
In some cases the heading is long enough that it is indented the same
as body text. The example below is the heading at the top of an
Extensions of Remarks file. The first line of Representative Eleanor
Holmes Norton's bill title is indented two spaces, the same indent as
the first line of a paragraph. That is not a problem for a heading at
the top of a file. It is more of a problem when that indent appears in
title case, deeper in the body of an .htm file. An example
of that is shown next.
INTRODUCTION OF THE FEDERAL POLICE CAMERA AND ACCOUNTABILITY ACT OF
2023
______
HON. ELEANOR HOLMES NORTON
of the district of columbia
in the house of representatives
Monday, February 6, 2023
Ms. NORTON. Mr. Speaker, today, I, along with Representative Donald
S. Beyer, Jr., introduce the Federal Police Camera and Accountability
Act of 2023. This bill would require uniformed federal law enforcement
officers to wear body cameras and marked federal law enforcement
vehicles to have dashboard cameras. It would also require the
Representative Claudia Tenney's title-case heading below,
Recognizing Priscilla ``Peep'' Williams for her Athletic and
Academic, is indented at the same level as the first line of
body text.
Recognizing the Life of Joe Fusco, Jr.
Ms. TENNEY. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize the tragic passing
of one of my district's great public servants, the Honorable Joseph
Recognizing Priscilla ``Peep'' Williams for her Athletic and Academic
Achievements
Ms. TENNEY. Mr. Speaker, I rise today to recognize Ms. Priscilla,
also known as Peep, Williams, a standout athlete and student from New
Due to these quirks of indentation, one must be careful when parsing
CREC .htm files and use other cues like blank space above
and below the title rather than indentation alone.
Printing Variation 7
Variation · Heading
A section title that does not describe the debate beneath it
Description
A title names the subject of the page. However, that is not
always what the speakers are talking about. An example is the November 2, 2023
debate opened by Representative Michelle Fischbach of Minnesota. The
title lists three appropriations bills.
Representative Fischbach starts as usual: by direction of the
Committee on Rules, she calls up House Resolution 838, the
resolution whose title is printed above the debate.
PROVIDING FOR CONSIDERATION OF H.R. 4821, DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR,
ENVIRONMENT, AND RELATED AGENCIES APPROPRIATIONS ACT, 2024; PROVIDING
FOR CONSIDERATION OF H.R. 4820, TRANSPORTATION, HOUSING AND URBAN
DEVELOPMENT, AND RELATED AGENCIES APPROPRIATIONS ACT, 2024; AND
PROVIDING FOR CONSIDERATION OF H.R. 6126, ISRAEL SECURITY SUPPLEMENTAL
APPROPRIATIONS ACT, 2024
Mrs. FISCHBACH. Mr. Speaker, by direction of the Committee on Rules,
I call up House Resolution 838 and ask for its immediate consideration.
However, not all of the remarks that follow are about the
resolution, or about the more general topic of those
appropriations bills. Representative Jim McGovern of Massachusetts instead
speaks about delaying aid to Israel.
Mr. McGOVERN. Madam Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may
consume.
Again, let's make no mistake about it, my Republican friends are
deliberately delaying aid to Israel. They are deliberately delaying aid
to Israel.
How our parser handles it
We aim to make titles descriptive of their content. McGovern's
remarks on aid to Israel do not match the debate's title or the
nature of the other speakers' statements.
However, removing McGovern's statement and placing it under its own
title would be an overcorrection: it would put too much weight on
the continuity between a title and its content, and not enough on
the continuity of the debate as a whole. There are cases where that
tradeoff shifts and we do retitle statements.
One example is a unanimous consent request. GPO prints those pages
with a title that describes the procedure, not the speech. An
example is the Senate page of March 30, 2022, where Senator Tammy
Baldwin of Wisconsin speaks in support of a nominee.
UNANIMOUS CONSENT REQUEST--EXECUTIVE CALENDAR
Ms. BALDWIN. Mr. President, I rise today in support of Jerry Kang,
President Biden's nominee to serve on the National Foundation on the
Arts and Humanities.
We keep a title when it describes the debate, as with House
Resolution 838 above. We generate a title for the speech when
there is no title, or when the printed title is procedural
and there are substantive floor statements under it. Procedural
titles include UNANIMOUS CONSENT,
POINT OF ORDER, and PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.
Baldwin's statement has that kind of title, so we replace it and
store the statement as Support for Jerry Kang Nomination.
Printing Variation 8
Variation · Heading
Capitals and title case used for headings at the same level
Description
Another entry in Part I covers a heading printed entirely in lowercase, which is an
error. Even without that error, GPO prints titles in two different
casings: capitals and title case. The first title on a page is
usually in capitals and the titles after it in title case. The two
casings are not a hierarchy: a title in title case is not a
subheading of the one in capitals above it, but a separate item at
the same level.
The example below shows both casings on one page. Representative
Earl L. “Buddy” Carter's twenty-one tributes of 14 May 2026
are printed with one heading in capitals and sixteen in title case, and each
heading opens a separate tribute.
RECOGNIZING GRIFF LYNCH
Mr. CARTER of Georgia. Madam Speaker, I rise today to recognize Griff
Lynch for his outstanding service as president and CEO of the Georgia
Ports Authority.
Honoring Life and Legacy of Ted Turner
Mr. CARTER of Georgia. Madam Speaker, I rise today to honor the life
and the legacy of Ted Turner, the founder of CNN and a former Savannah
resident.
Honoring the Legacy of William Ligon III
Mr. CARTER of Georgia. Madam Speaker, I rise today to honor the
memory and the legacy of William Ligon III. Will tragically passed on
May 3 after a life full of compassion and service to others.
A parser that accepts only titles in capitals will miss every title
printed in title case. To parse all of them, a parser has to allow
both casings.
Byline lookalikes
Printing Variation 9
Variation · Name list
Name lists that wrap onto their own line
Description
A byline is typically an honorific, a surname in capitals, and a
period, then the speech. An example is Representative Jim Costa of
California.
Mr. COSTA. Madam Speaker, I rise today to honor Nhia Long Vang, a
Some lines have the same form as a byline but are not bylines. One
example is the Additional Sponsors section, which lists each bill
number followed by the Members who signed on as cosponsors. When a
list is too long for one line it wraps, and the name that lands on the new line has the same form as a standard byline. The list for
H.R. 1282 is shown below, where
Mr. Butterfield. begins a line of its own.
H.R. 1219: Ms. Schakowsky.
H.R. 1282: Mr. Smith of New Jersey, Ms. Ocasio-Cortez, and
Mr. Butterfield.
H.R. 1579: Ms. Porter.
H.R. 1696: Mr. Doggett.
A parser that works line by line could read
Mr. Butterfield. as a byline: with the leading
whitespace removed, it has the same format as a real byline.
How our parser handles it
We maintain a list of procedural titles and skip parsing if the title
is on that list. ADDITIONAL SPONSORS is one example of a title on our procedural title list.
Printing Variation 10
Variation · Line wrap
A name inside a sentence that happens to start a line
Description
The Record wraps at a fixed column width with no regard for what
lands at the start of a line. Any name mentioned mid-sentence can be
pushed to the beginning of the next line. If the sentence happens to
end after the name, it can take a similar format to a standard
byline. An example of a real byline is Senator Ben Cardin of
Maryland.
Mr. CARDIN. Mr. President, section 36(b) of the Arms Export Control
Act requires that Congress receive prior notification of certain
One example of the wrap is a tribute by Representative Rashida
Tlaib of Michigan. A song title lands at the start of a line as
Mr. Postman., which has the same format as a
byline.
Motown one of its biggest hits with their best-known song, ``Please,
Mr. Postman.''
Wanda Young sang lead on many of the Marvelettes' recordings,
including hit songs ``Don't Mess Around with Bill'' and ``I'll Keep
A parser that works line by line could read
Mr. Postman. as a byline: it has the same format
as Mr. CARDIN. above. A parser can differentiate
this from a normal byline because the line does not follow the
usual pattern: a period after the name, then the opening of a
statement, such as Mr. Speaker or I rise.
How our parser handles it
The surname is also matched against our database of Members, as in
Printing Error 15, and no Member is named Postman.
Printing Variation 11
Variation · Procedural
A parenthetical printed above a byline
Description
Sometimes a statement is preceded by a parenthetical that names the
Member and says they were given permission to address the House.
The line sits directly above the speech and is not a byline: the
speech begins on the line after it. An example is Representative
Glenn Thompson of Pennsylvania.
RECOGNIZING READ ACROSS AMERICA
(Mr. THOMPSON of Pennsylvania asked and was given permission to address
the House for 1 minute and to revise and extend his remarks.)
Mr. THOMPSON of Pennsylvania. Mr. Speaker, I rise to recognize
Read Across America Week. On Sunday, we kicked off Read Across America
Day, marking the start of National Reading Month.
A parser can differentiate this parenthetical from a normal byline
because the line opens with a parenthesis, and because the
sentence continues after the name rather than ending in a period
and then an address such as Mr. Speaker.
Layout conventions
Printing Variation 12
Variation · Editorial note
An editorial note
Description
When GPO catches an error it leaves the original line in
place and inserts an editorial note recording what was printed and
what the online version should read. The note is often dropped into
the middle of a statement, sometimes mid-sentence. An example is
shown below.
An example is Representative Sheila Jackson Lee of Texas, speaking
on 20 January 2022 in support of the Ensuring Veterans' Smooth
Transition Act. After her opening paragraph GPO inserts a note
correcting Mrs JACKSON LEE. to
Ms. JACKSON LEE. The speech then continues.
Ms. JACKSON LEE. Mr. Speaker, I stand here in strong support of H.R.
1836, the Ensuring Veterans' Smooth Transition Act (EVEST), which
provides automatic enrollment in the VA for all transitioning service
members, and veterans who don't want to obtain its services have the
easy choice of opting out.
=========================== NOTE ===========================
January 20, 2022, on page H263, in the third column, the
following appeared: Mrs JACKSON LEE. Mr. Speaker, I stand here in
strong support of H.R. 1836, the Ensuring Veterans' Smooth
Transition Act
The online version has been corrected to read: Ms. JACKSON LEE.
Mr. Speaker, I stand here in strong support of H.R. 1836, the
Ensuring Veterans' Smooth Transition Act
========================= END NOTE =========================
Specifically, this bill would:
Automatically enroll new veterans into VA Health Care;
A note can also sit mid-sentence. An example is Representative
Rosa DeLauro of Connecticut, in a tribute to Doris “Deb”
Biesterfeld Townshend on 6 November 2023. The sentence opens
leaders will gather to, then the note, then continues
remember one of the City of New Haven's greatest
treasures.
Ms. DeLAURO. Mr. Speaker, today, family, friends, and community
leaders will gather to
=========================== NOTE ===========================
On November 6, 2023, page E1061, in the second column, the
following appeared: Mr. DELAURO. Mr. Speaker, today, family,
friends, and community leaders will gather to
The online version has been corrected to read: Ms. DELAURO. Mr.
Speaker, today, family, friends, and community leaders will gather
to
========================= END NOTE =========================
remember one of the City of New Haven's greatest treasures, Doris
``Deb'' Biesterfeld Townshend, who we lost in September of 2020.
Left in place, the note is stored as if the Member said it. Both the
NOTE and END NOTE lines are all caps, with
blank lines around them, so a title detector can treat either as a
title. Everything under that title is then stored as the content of a
new statement. A parser that strips the whole note, including the
NOTE and END NOTE lines, before title
detection avoids this.
How our parser handles it
We remove complete NOTE … END NOTE
blocks from the page text before the rest of processing runs. If the
text before the block ends a sentence, we leave a paragraph break. If
the block sits mid-sentence, we compress the line breaks to a space,
so will gather to remember reads as one sentence.
Printing Variation 13
Variation · Layout
Page and time markers printed in the body of a statement
Description
Because the Record is set as a printed version first, and then
transferred to .htm files, GPO adds the pages as an
annotation in the files. GPO marks where a new page begins using
the format [[Page H274]]. These markers appear in the
body of remarks, often between two sentences of the same speech.
Likewise the House and Senate floors keep a running clock, and GPO
marks the time in the format {time} 1215. An example
of each, from the same House file of 20 January 2022, is shown
below.
Mr. CORREA. Mr. Speaker, today we honor the life and memory of Manny
T. Padilla, a leader in our community and my very, very good friend.
[[Page H274]]
Manny served on many boards, commissions, and organizations in Orange
County, and he also served 9 years on the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
of Orange County's Board of Directors.
President Trump even promised that he would be the one person to get it
done. But he didn't, not even when Republicans controlled the House,
Senate, and Presidency.
{time} 1215
It was President Biden and this Democratic Congress that finally got
it done even though more than 90 percent of my Republican colleagues
voted against it.
Left in place, a page or time marker would be stored as part of the
statement text.
How our parser handles it
We keep page markers so we can record which pages a
statement was printed on, then remove them from the statement text,
collapsing the hole to a line break.
We strip time markers before title detection and statement assembly.
Printing Variation 14
Variation · Layout
A change of presiding officer
Description
The Senate is presided over by a presiding officer, whom Members
address as “Mr. President” or “Madam
President,” depending on who holds the chair. The Vice
President, who is formally the President of the Senate, rarely
presides. The duty then falls to the President pro tempore, a Senator
the Senate elects to preside when the Vice President is absent, by
custom the longest-serving member of the majority party. In practice,
however, the President pro tempore rarely presides either. Instead,
the President pro tempore designates Senators of the majority party,
usually junior ones, to preside in shifts of about an hour, so the
chair changes hands several times a day. GPO records each change in
the Congressional Record with a one-line note in parentheses.
Occasionally the change happens in the middle of a Member’s
speech, and the note is printed at that point in the speech. In some
cases, the note is the first line of a file, before any byline.
In the example below, from September 7, 2022, Senator Hickenlooper
takes the chair partway through Senator Durbin’s speech on
student debt. Durbin opens with “Madam President,”
continues after the note with “Mr. President,” and refers
to the change in that sentence (“before the Presiding Officer
arrived”).
[Congressional Record Volume 168, Number 143 (Wednesday, September 7, 2022)]
[Senate]
[Pages S4458-S4460]
Student Loan Debt Relief Plan
Mr. DURBIN. Madam President, October 4, 1957. Many in the Chamber
were not alive at that date. I was. I was a teenager, maybe in high
school, just starting, or at the end of grade school. But it was a big
day in the history of the world, October 4, 1957, because at 7:28 p.m.
at night, the Russians launched Sputnik.
So what happened? We know. A lot of people got too deeply in debt. It
turned out that even the promise of a college diploma was not enough to
meet their obligations, so they are deeply in debt.
(Mr. HICKENLOOPER assumed the Chair.)
Now, Mr. President, let me mention a third category of things that
started before the Presiding Officer arrived. There was Sputnik which
changed the world and the National Defense Education Act; we went and
changed the bankruptcy law and said that you can't discharge a student
loan in bankruptcy.
The note usually sits on its own line as in the example above, but
sometimes the speaker’s next sentence starts on the same line.
In the example below, from April 5, 2022, Senator Markey takes the
chair during Senator Bennet’s speech on the child tax credit,
and Bennet’s next sentence begins right after the note.
[Congressional Record Volume 168, Number 60 (Tuesday, April 5, 2022)]
[Senate]
[Pages S1965-S1968]
Child Tax Credit
Mr. BENNET. Mr. President, I appreciate the opportunity to address
the Senate on an issue of real importance to our country and to
families in Colorado and all across the United States.
actually reinforcing the income equality we have rather than liberating
people from their circumstances.
(Mr. MARKEY assumed the Chair.) The best predictor of the quality of
your education in this country is your parents' income, to the point of
ruthlessness--to the point of ruthlessness.
In the example below, from December 3, 2009, the Senate came back
from a recess with Senator Whitehouse presiding. The debate continues
in a new file, which opens with Senator Shaheen taking the chair, and
Whitehouse then speaks from the floor.
[Congressional Record Volume 155, Number 178 (Thursday, December 3, 2009)]
[Senate]
[Pages S12300-S12317]
SERVICE MEMBERS HOME OWNERSHIP TAX ACT OF 2009--(Continued)
(Mrs. SHAHEEN assumed the Chair.)
Mr. WHITEHOUSE. I suggest the absence of a quorum.
The PRESIDING OFFICER. The clerk will call the roll.
How our parser handles it
The note is not part of the Member’s speech, so we remove it
from the statement text we store. When the speaker’s next
sentence shares the note’s line, only the note is removed and
the sentence stays in the statement. When the note is the first line
of a file, it is likewise left out of every statement.
Printing Variation 15
Variation · Layout
A statement printed in the floor proceedings but never spoken
Description
Written remarks normally go in the Extensions of Remarks section
of the Record. That section holds statements unrelated to the
day’s legislation, such as tributes and personal
explanations of missed votes.
Written statements about a bill being debated are handled
differently. During the debate, the bill manager usually asks
unanimous consent that all Members have five legislative days to
revise and extend their remarks on the bill. This is called general
leave. A statement submitted under general leave on the day of the
debate is printed at the end of that debate, in the House section.
A statement submitted on a later day goes to Extensions of Remarks
instead.
These written statements printed as part of general leave use the
same byline format as the spoken statements around them. To
distinguish them from the spoken statements in the same debate, the
House sets them in Helvetica, a sans-serif typeface, instead of the
serif typeface used for the rest of the proceedings. A legend at the
foot of the first page of each day’s House section explains
this typeface difference to readers.
An example is Representative Eddie Bernice Johnson of Texas on 29
November 2022, in the debate on S. 231, the PFAS Act.
Representative Haley Stevens yields back her time, and
Johnson’s written statement follows in Helvetica.
The Senate handles written statements differently. A Senator hands
a written statement to the clerk at the desk in the Senate chamber.
It is printed in the Senate section, not in Extensions of Remarks,
and is usually gathered with other written statements under the
heading “Additional Statements.” It is printed with a
debate only when the Senate’s reporters judge that it belongs
there. To distinguish these written statements from spoken ones,
the Senate prints a bullet before the byline and another after the
last word. The bullet is used only when no part of the statement was
spoken. A legend on the first page of each day’s Senate
section explains the bullet to readers.
An example is Senator John Barrasso’s tribute to Devlin Birnie,
an intern in his office, printed the same day.
The .htm file keeps none of the House typeface. In the
file for the same pages, Johnson’s statement looks the same as
the spoken statements around it.
deliver for the American people.
Mr. Speaker, I yield back the balance of my time.
Ms. JOHNSON of Texas. Mr. Speaker, I rise today in strong support of
S. 231, the Protecting Firefighters from Adverse Substances Act or the
PFAS Act.
A Member can also speak and then have a prepared text appended under
the same byline. Earlier in the same debate, Representative Sheila
Jackson Lee closes her spoken remarks and her prepared statement
follows. In the PDF the second paragraph below starts the inserted
typeface.
Mr. Speaker, as I conclude my remarks celebrating the firefighters
and supporting this legislation, let me say: Go USA against Iran.
Mr. Speaker, as a senior member of the House Committee on Homeland
Security, I rise in strong support of S. 231, the Protecting
Firefighters from Adverse Substances Act.
The Senate’s bullet survives in the .htm file as a
literal <bullet>. An example is Senator Chris
Murphy’s tribute to Suffield, Connecticut, on 25 October 2021,
which also has his surname misspelled in the byline.
350TH ANNIVERSARY OF SUFFIELD, CONNECTICUT
<bullet> Mr. MURPHPY. Madam President, I rise today to commemorate the
grateful to represent a town with such a storied past and an equally
bright future.<bullet>
The same <bullet> is also used for ordinary list
items, as in this summary of the 2023 omnibus appropriations bill
printed on 20 December 2022.
providing disaster relief, and other matter. The divisions
contained in the Act are as follows:
<bullet> Division A--Agriculture, Rural Development, Food
and Drug Administration, and Related Agencies Appropriations
Act, 2023
<bullet> Division B--Commerce, Justice, Science, and
Related Agencies Appropriations Act, 2023
The closing bullet is also sometimes left out. Senator Tom
Cotton’s tribute to Denman Wolfe on 5 February 2020 opens with
a bullet and ends without one.
REMEMBERING DENMAN WOLFE
<bullet> Mr. COTTON. Mr. President, Denman Wolfe of Scottsville, AR,
In every aspect of life, Rangers lead the way. Denman Wolfe took this
motto to heart during his long life. Now he is leading the way again,
going ahead of us to our eternal home. May he rest in peace.
____________________
None of the parsers described at the top of this dictionary marks a
statement as written or spoken. The congressional-record parser
accepts <bullet> in front of a byline, but only
to find where a new speaker begins. Its output has six item types
(speech, recorder, clerk, linebreak, excerpt, and rollcall), and a
bulleted Senate tribute comes out as a speech. ProPublica’s
Capitol Words code does not mention the bullet or the typeface, and
the documentation for the Stanford dataset does not mention either.
From the .htm files alone, the House typeface cannot be
recovered at all. The Senate bullet can, but the same tag also marks
list items, and the closing bullet is sometimes missing, as in the
examples above.
As described elsewhere in this dictionary, GPO also publishes mods.xml, a
metadata file with an entry for each article in the day’s
Record. An article’s entry can carry a
hasInsertedComments flag, but it does not mark which
statements were written. The flag is set only on Senate articles,
and it covers the whole article rather than the written statement
in it. In our examination it was also sometimes missing from Senate
articles that contain a written statement.
How our parser handles it
Unlike these parsers, we mark each statement as written or spoken.
For the House we use the PDF of the House section, since the
typeface is not recorded anywhere else. We extract the PDF’s
text character by character, along with the font each character is
set in. We then match the text of each statement we store to that
text, character by character, so every character of the statement
gets the font it was printed in. A character set in Helvetica is
written. A character set in the body typeface, at the size used for
bylines, is spoken. Headings and quoted letters are set in a smaller
size, so their characters take the label of the characters around
them. A statement with no spoken passage is marked written.
For the Senate we read the <bullet> tags in the
.htm files. A <bullet> at the start
of a line starts a written statement only when a byline follows it,
which rules out list bullets. The statement ends at the next
<bullet>, or at the next byline when the closing
bullet is missing. We checked this against the bullets in the PDF
for 2020 to 2026, and the two sources agree on every Senate
statement we checked, so the .htm files alone are a reliable
source for the Senate.
When only part of a statement is written, as in Jackson Lee’s
example above, we keep the statement as spoken and store the
character ranges of the written part. In our sample from 2020 to
2026, 4,022 statements are written and 408 are partly written.
Printing Variation 16
Variation · Byline
A byline with nothing after it
Description
A Member’s turn to speak begins with a byline: an honorific,
the surname in capitals, possibly a state, and a closing period. The
Member’s words then start on the same line, after the period.
When a Member reads a passage aloud, such as a letter or a newspaper
article, GPO prints the passage as an indented block below the line
where the Member’s own words begin. The Member usually says
something before reading, such as “Madam President, I continue
the reading of the letter,” and those words go after the
byline as usual. In some cases a Member starts reading at once
without saying anything first. GPO then prints the byline alone on
its line, with the passage below it. From 2009 to 2026 we found 11
such bylines on five days. Most come from the Senate’s yearly
reading of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s “Letter From
Birmingham Jail,” in which Senators take turns reading
passages of the letter.
In the example below, from April 14, 2021, Senator Murkowski
introduces her passage, so her words follow her byline as usual.
Later in the same reading, Senator Cassidy starts reading at once,
so his byline is printed alone on its line.
[Congressional Record Volume 167, Number 64 (Wednesday, April 14, 2021)]
[Senate]
[Pages S1917-S1921]
The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Senator from Alaska.
Ms. MURKOWSKI. Madam President, I continue the reading of the letter
from Birmingham jail:
You may well ask: ``Why direct action? Why sit ins, marches
and so forth? Isn't negotiation a better path?'' You are
ideologies--a development that would inevitably lead to a
frightening racial nightmare.
The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Senator from Louisiana
Mr. CASSIDY.
Oppressed people cannot remain oppressed forever. The
yearning for freedom eventually manifests itself, and that is
In some cases the byline is that of the Member who is already
speaking. In the example below, from March 5, 2010, Senator LeMieux
asks to have an Associated Press article printed in the Record
during his speech on Latin America. After the article, he starts
reading from it at once, so his byline is printed again, alone on its
line, with the passage he reads below it. He then continues his
speech.
[Congressional Record Volume 156, Number 31 (Friday, March 5, 2010)]
[Senate]
[Pages S1212-S1225]
I have another article that I ask unanimous consent to have printed
in the Record from the Associated Press by Curt Anderson. ``Three men
charged in Miami with financing Hezbollah.''
There being no objection, the material was ordered to be printed in
the Record, as follows:
[From the Associated Press, Feb. 19, 2010]
Three Men Charged in Miami With Financing Hezbollah
(By Curt Anderson)
Miami.--Three men were charged in an indictment unsealed
Friday with illegally exporting electronics and video games
holding seats in Lebanon's parliament as well as two Cabinet
posts.
Mr. LeMIEUX.
Three men were charged in an indictment unsealed Friday
with illegally exporting electronics and video games to a
South American shopping center that U.S. officials claim
funnels money to a Hezbollah militant group.
In his book ``The Gathering Storm,'' Winston Churchill described all
the failed attempts and all the missed opportunities of Europe in the
How our parser handles it
A byline printed alone on its line still starts the Member’s
turn, and the passage below it becomes the start of the
Member’s statement. When the byline repeats the name of the
Member already speaking, our parser adds the passage to that
Member’s current statement instead of starting a new one.
← Back to the engineering blog