We sued Anthropic for $20 and won (kind of).
A broken login, two months of support requests, and a small-claims case in San Francisco.
We use a number of AI tools in our pipeline and workflow, including Claude which we use for research and writing for this engineering blog and our executive actions posts.
One day in late April, we opened Claude and were prompted to log in. This was a little unusual because cookies normally kept us logged in, but we went through the standard magic link process. Instead of opening our existing account, the link took us to a page asking us to create one.
We’d had the account for two years, so we assumed this was a bug and tried again. When we got the same screen, we decided to wait until the next day in case it was a temporary problem. The next day, though, we were still being asked to create an account. We didn’t want to proceed through that flow without knowing what would happen to our existing conversations.
Trying to get support
We went looking for a support email address but couldn’t find one. Instead, we were directed to Fin, Anthropic’s AI support agent. Fin walked us through the standard troubleshooting steps, like clearing the browser cache and checking the email address, but offered no help beyond that.
Over the next few days, we tried clearing cookies and cache, using incognito mode, switching browsers, and logging in from another computer. Eventually, we tried a different computer in a completely different location with a different internet connection. We also tried the desktop app, but every attempt brought us back to account creation.
Claude still worked on our iPhone and iPad, where we could see the account, subscription, and existing conversations. That didn’t help us do our work, though. Our code, IDE, and terminal setup was on our computer, and we used Claude alongside those tools. Having access on an iPad wasn’t a substitute for being able to use it in our normal setup.
We returned to Fin and went through the troubleshooting conversation again. By April 29, with no meaningful support, we were at our wits’ end.
“YES! This is the 3rd time we have spoken Fin. The email I am using is correct. The URL is correct. Yes I have tried clearing cookies and using Incognito mode. Yes I have tried multiple devices.”
After our outburst, Fin finally said it had forwarded the issue to a member of the support team. We received an email acknowledging the request and were told it could take up to 48 hours to get a response.
Several days passed without a response from a person, so we followed up on May 4. No response. We followed up again on May 7. Then again on May 10. Then on May 14, and again on May 22. By then, almost a month had passed since our first written request.
While waiting, we considered going through account creation again. Perhaps the login screen was wrong and completing the steps would simply return us to our existing account rather than create a new one. Before risking our conversation history, we searched to see whether other users had tried it. We found a Reddit thread discussing the same problem. Many people in the thread were still unable to access their accounts, and some who had gone through account creation said their chats were missing afterward. A few reported getting their chats back, but that wasn’t reassuring enough for us to risk it. We included the thread in our May 4 follow-up to Anthropic. We also tried one suggestion from the discussion, removing the Claude browser extension, but it didn’t help.
We couldn’t cancel the subscription either
While waiting for support, we thought we could at least cancel or pause the paid subscription until we could use Claude on our computer again. We opened the billing settings in the mobile app, where our Pro plan was still visible, but trying to manage it brought up this message.
“This subscription cannot be cancelled or changed within this app because it was purchased on another platform. To manage your subscription, please log in to your account where you made the purchase.”
We had subscribed through the website, so the app was sending us back to the web account we couldn’t access. We were still being charged $20 a month, and our support requests hadn’t produced any help.
Considering our options
With support going nowhere, we decided to ask Claude’s competitor, ChatGPT, about our options. Given the similar complaints on Reddit, we wondered whether we could bring a class action with other affected users. ChatGPT recommended against that approach.
A few days later, we had another idea. We could sue Anthropic in small-claims court for our $20 monthly subscription fee. We’d never done that before, and it sounded like a fun adventure that would at least leave us with a story to tell.
We also decided to submit consumer complaints to the New York and California attorneys general because we were still being charged for a subscription we couldn’t manage or cancel, and other users appeared to be having the same problem.
The California Attorney General’s Office sent back a generic response, but the New York Attorney General’s Office later told us it was forwarding our complaint and supporting documents to Anthropic to request a statement of the company’s position. That response arrived in September, after the account issue had been resolved.
On May 29, we sent Anthropic a final demand through the existing email thread. We asked for access to our account and a refund of the $20 May subscription charge, and gave the company seven days to resolve the issue before we would file in small-claims court.
Filing a $20 claim
The deadline passed without a response, so we went ahead with the claim. We live in New York but filed in San Francisco, where Anthropic was based and where its terms said disputes would be heard. We needed form SC-100, the plaintiff’s claim. We named Anthropic, Inc. as the defendant and requested the $20 May subscription payment.
San Francisco does not offer electronic filing for small-claims cases. We had to go to a FedEx store to print every form, fill them out by hand, and make two additional copies of the claim. We wrote a $30 check for the court filing fee and included a self-addressed stamped envelope so the court could mail the filed copies back to us. Then we shipped the packet to the court. The court mailed back two filed copies with a hearing date of August 6, 2026.
Then, just like in the movies, we had to serve them. We found Anthropic’s California registered agent, CSC (Lawyers Incorporating Service), in Sacramento and hired California Civil Process to serve the papers there. We scanned the court-stamped papers with a phone and sent them to the process server, who charged $55.
The process server first tried to deliver the papers on July 2, but the building was locked because of a reported power outage. They returned on July 6 and successfully served Anthropic’s registered agent. We received a notification after each attempt.
Since we were in New York, we also requested permission to attend the hearing by Zoom using the court’s Zoom request packet, SFSCL-005. That required another set of documents, including a request, a declaration about notifying Anthropic, and a proposed order for the judge to sign. Those had to be mailed to the court too.
The evidence packet also had to be submitted on paper, which meant another trip to the FedEx store to print the statement and every exhibit. We made copies for the court and Anthropic, then shipped the packets to the court and to Anthropic through its registered agent. The packet contained the following documents.
- Our statement and timeline. An account of the login problem, troubleshooting attempts, support requests, and inability to manage the subscription. By July, we were requesting $60 for three months of subscription charges.
- Exhibit 1. The onboarding screen. A screenshot showing that signing in with our existing email address took us to “Create account.”
- Exhibit 2. Mobile billing. Screenshots showing the Pro plan and the message directing us to the website to cancel or change the subscription.
- Exhibit 3. Proof of payment. Receipt screenshots showing the $20 Claude Pro charge for each of the three months, May, June, and July.
- Exhibit 4. The support thread. Our April 29 request, Anthropic’s acknowledgment, and our follow-ups through May 22.
- Exhibit 5. Other users’ reports. A printout of the Reddit discussion, included as background showing that other users had reported similar problems.
- Exhibit 8. Anthropic’s Consumer Terms. The provisions on account closure, automatic renewal, cancellation, and the liability cap that we cited in our argument.
The terms we included in the evidence packet
Exhibit 8 was a copy of Anthropic’s Consumer Terms of Service, effective October 8, 2025. We identified four provisions relevant to our claim.
- Section 2. Account closure. Users could close an account at any time by contacting [email protected].
- Section 6. Automatic renewal. Paid subscriptions renewed automatically and charges continued until cancellation.
- Section 6(3). Subscription cancellation. Website subscribers could cancel through the customer portal or by notifying [email protected].
- Section 11. Liability cap. The stated cap was the greater of $100 or the amount paid in the six months before the issue arose. Our requested refund was within that cap.
In our statement to the court, we argued that Anthropic had violated its own terms because neither cancellation route was working. The login problem blocked the customer portal, and repeated contacts with support hadn’t restored access, cancelled or downgraded the subscription, or produced a refund.
Between the filing fee, service, printing, and shipping, the whole thing cost approximately $250.
| Expense | Cost |
|---|---|
| Court filing fee | $30 |
| Process server | $55 |
| FedEx printing, shipping, and computer use | Approximately $165 |
| Total | Approximately $250 |
Printing and shipping at FedEx were surprisingly expensive. We also had to pay by the minute to use a computer to open our email and retrieve the documents we’d emailed ourselves to print. Together, printing, shipping, and computer use account for roughly $165 of the estimated total after subtracting the filing and service fees. We were spending far more than the subscription charge, but again, the point was to go on an adventure.
Suing Anthropic caught their attention
On July 16, three days after we sent in the evidence packet, Anthropic reached out. We can’t be sure the lawsuit prompted the response, but after months of asking for help without a meaningful human reply, the timing suggests it got their attention.
Anthropic confirmed that our account had been caught in an onboarding loop and said it had processed a refund for the three months we couldn’t use the service.
We got access to the account and our existing conversations back, and the case didn’t need to go to a hearing. We did, however, have to dismiss it. By then we were on vacation on the West Coast, so we had to go to FedEx one last time to print CIV-110, Request for Dismissal, fill it out, and mail it to the court.
And that, my friends, is how we sued Anthropic for $20 in small claims court and won, kind of.